patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Court Case

Monday, March 4, 2013

No Closure in Wells Sherman House Court Case

Magistrate hears attorneys' arguments, gives time for written briefs

The court case over the relocation of the historic Kent Wells Sherman House to greenspace on North Water Street continued Friday in Portage County Common Pleas Court. Portage Magistrate Kent Graham listened to attorneys for the city of Kent, the non-profit Kent Wells Sherman House Inc. and Save the Standing Rock Garden — the group trying to prevent the relocation — without ruling on the matter. Friday's hearing was held so attorneys could argue their cases over Save the Standing Rock Garden's request for a permanent injuction to halt the relocation of the house to the lot at 247 N. Water St., which is owned by Kent Wells Sherman House Inc. After less than an hour Graham told the attorneys they had until mid March for John Plough, counsel …

Mars

10:05 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Everybody needs beauty as well as bread, places to play in and pray in, where Nature may heal and cheer and give strength to body and soul alike. ~John Muir   more ›

Monday, February 4, 2013

Judge Rules on Objections in Wells Sherman House Case

Request for oral hearing in case is denied

A Portage County judge has ruled that the court case over the relocation of a historic Kent house should not be reopened for further oral arguments. Portage County Common Pleas Judge John Enlow issued a ruling in the ongoing court case between two groups, the Kent Wells Sherman House, Inc., and Save the Standing Rock Garden, over the relocation of the Kent Wells Sherman House to the lot at 247 N. Water St. Enlow's ruling was issued in response to an objection to an earlier ruling in the case by Portage County Magistrate Kent Graham. The objection to Graham's ruling had been filed by Kent attorney John Plough on behalf of Save the Standing Rock Garden. Plough had argued in his objection, filed in December, that Graham had erred in his …

Wednesday, January 16, 2013

Wells Sherman House Court Case Not Over

Group files objection to magistrate's ruling

The struggle persists over the relocation of a historic Kent house to a cherished piece of greenspace. Kent attorney John Plough, representing members of the group Save the Standing Rock Garden, who oppose the relocation of the Kent Wells Sherman House to 247 N. Water St., has filed an objection to a magistrate's decision in the court case about the issue. In December Portage County Magistrate Kent Graham denied three injunction requests made by Save the Standing Rock Garden in an effort to stop the relocation of the house to the lot, which has been used — but not owned — for decades by members of neighboring Kent arts group Standing Rock Cultural Arts. Plough had asked the court for injunctions in November against the Kent Wells Sherman …

Mike Reynolds

10:06 am on Friday, January 25, 2013

It would be much more appropriate and culturally sensitive to the vibrant close knit community here to just take a few photos of the KWSH and then dismantle it. Use the historic timbers to make fittings for Ray's (an actual historic landmark) or something useful, or take any actual historic artifacts from the house and put them on display at Kent State as a part of a permanent exhibit on Kent …   more ›

Saturday, December 1, 2012

Deadline for Moving Kent Wells Sherman House Extended

Portage magistrate denies request for preliminary injunction to stop relocation of house to North Water Street lot

Today's deadline threatening demolition of the Kent Wells Sherman House if it was not moved from land owned by Kent State University appears flexible after all. News came Friday that a Portage County magistrate had denied a request from a group of Kent residents looking to stop the relocation of the historic house to a vacant lot at 247 N. Water St. The house, which had to be moved for construction of Kent State's Esplanade extension, was temporary relocated to a small parcel of university land at the western end of East College Avenue in August. Both university and city officials said the house had to be moved from that locale by today or it would be demolished so it did not interfere with city plow trucks that use that dead-end portion …

Patch_comments_icon

Matt Fredmonsky

12:13 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012

Comments were deleted for violating Patch's terms of use: http://kent.patch.com/terms   more ›

Friday, November 30, 2012

Court Decision Pending in Wells Sherman House Case

Final briefs filed by attorneys this week; magistrate's ruling pending

A court decision may be near in the case involving an appeal to stop the relocation of the historic Kent Wells Sherman House. Attorneys for three of the parties in the case, Save the Standing Rock Garden, Kent Wells Sherman House, Inc., and the city of Kent, all filed final briefs in the case Tuesday with Portage County magistrate Kent Graham. Kent attorney John Plough, representing the Standing Rock garden group that's trying to stop the relocation, filed an 11-page brief. The city of Kent filed a 28-page final brief, and the attorney for the Kent Wells Sherman House group filed a four-page final statement. It's unclear when Graham will deliver his order in the case. Stay tuned to Kent Patch for updates to this story. RECENT COVERAGE:

Misty Jones

12:32 pm on Friday, November 30, 2012

Unbiased reporting not to mention a review of the dockets online would state what the appeal with injunction request actually is about: an appeal to the planning commission decision and alleged violation of sunshine law. You should know better, Patch.   more ›

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Court Ends Testimony on Wells Sherman House Injunction Request

Portage magistrate closes second, full day of trial

A court decision may be near in the case involving an appeal to stop the relocation of the historic Kent Wells Sherman House. Portage County Magistrate Kent Graham listened to a second, full day of witness testimony Wednesday before making several modifications to a temporary injunction order regarding the relocation of the house to 247 N. Water St. Kent Assistant Law Director Eric Fink said in a telephone interview after the court proceedings concluded Wednesday that Graham had ordered the final arguments and trial briefs be submitted to the court by Tuesday at 4 p.m. "There will be no further testimony taken," Fink said. Kent attorney John Plough, who is arguing the case on behalf of the Kent citizens' group "Save the Standing Rock …

Comment_arrow

jim

7:19 pm on Tuesday, November 27, 2012

David,you took the words right out of my mouth, thank you! This is about how government operates, not so much about who has the right to own and do what with their property. Its a case study in how a commission can be bullied into not doing its job, which is to hear the communities needs on property use, decide accordingly. They decided no, and shouldn't they; having heard testimony from most who…   more ›

Got a Hot Tip?