.
Feedback

Kent State Architecture College Proposals Unveiled

Design firms competing to create new, $40 million building on Esplanade pitched their plans to the Kent community

From simple and functional to splendidly provocative, four proposals vying to become reality as Kent State University's new College of Architecture and Environmental Design were presented to the public Thursday.

The university hosted the four partnerships competing to design the $40 million building by providing a forum so the architects could pitch their ideas for "solving the problem," as one presenter put it.

The challenge: capture the renewed town-gown synergy, combine it with the raw energy of architecture studios — filled with bright, young minds — and create a building that represents the symbolic and historic significance of a new link between the city and university.

"As far as I'm concerned this is more exciting than the finals of American Idol, the Oscars and the Super Bowl combined," Kent State President Lester Lefton said.

"One of the designs we unveil ... will be built on our Esplanade, the walkway that will soon extend directly into downtown Kent," Lefton said. "This landmark location makes a strong statement about the inextricable link between our campus and the city we've called home for more than a century."

The four partnerships remaining in the design competition are:

  • Bialosky + Partners Architects, with offices in New York and Cleveland, in association with Architecture Research Office of New York
  • WEISS/MANFREDI Lead Designer + Richard L. Bowen & Associates Architect, with offices in Cleveland and New York.
  • The Collaborative Inc. of Toledo, Ohio, in association with the Miller Hull Partnership of Seattle
  • Westlake Reed Leskosky with offices in Cleveland and four other cities

The four finalists were among an original 37 submissions from firms around the world who wanted to take part in the design competition.

A five-person jury will determine the winning firm, which will be announced in February. The jury is comprised of: Vivian Loftness, professor at Carnegie Mellon University; Brad Lynch, Brinistool+Lynch Architecture Design; Joan M. Soranno, vice president FAIA; Douglas Steidl, dean of Kent State's architecture school; and Michael Bruder, director of design and construction in Kent State's architecture office.

The 122,000 square foot building will be Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design certified, which means the building will be highly energy efficient per the internationally recognized green-building standards.

Models of the proposals with further renderings will be on display in the Kent State Library for public viewing. University officials are asking the public to offer feedback on the four proposals via email at caedcomments@kent.edu.

The $40 million architecture building is part of $170 million in renovations planned for the Kent campus.

"All told, the changes will be historic in size, scope and significance," Lefton said.

RELATED COVERAGE:

  • Kent State Names Finalists in Architecture College Design Competition
  • New Kent State Architecture Building to Stand on Esplanade
  • Video shows Kent State Renovation Plans
Desmo January 18, 2013 at 05:08 pm
It looks extremely similar to Ohio State's architecture building.
Matt Fredmonsky (Editor) January 18, 2013 at 05:27 pm
I believe you're referring to the Westlake, Reed Leskosky proposal looking similar to the Knowlton School of Architecture at Ohio State University? Someone else made the same connection. Here's a link to Ohio State's architecture college: knowlton.osu.edu/
Jim Williams January 19, 2013 at 03:33 pm
All uninspiring. I'm very disappointed the University stayed so local in their choices of firms to enter this "competition." So much great architecture happening, and we select boring to represent KSU.
Dale Pudloski January 19, 2013 at 06:53 pm
I'm glad they kept it local! Perhaps a Chinese architecture firm with Mexican builders would be more to your liking. I wonder why we have lost so many jobs!
Greg January 19, 2013 at 07:52 pm
I agree completely, the preliminary list of invited architects for this project had so many proven firms that build interesting conscientious designs in the academic realm of architecture i.e. Morphosis, OMA, SHop... To choose the finalists that they did shows the disrespect and lack of interest that Kent State has for their architecture program and the alumni, it is truly about the dollar signs.
As for Dales completely ignorant and offensive comment, I hope for the sake of the university that you have nothing to do with it.
Jim Williams January 19, 2013 at 08:56 pm
Oh fer cryin' out loud, does everything have to be taken down to the Rush Limbaugh level of understanding the world, Dale? Architecture is a reflection of the world we live in, and some of the best practitioners are found elsewhere. As a training ground for future architects, it was up to the University to find the most inspiring example to help show them the way. I don't feel any of these fits the bill. (well, one comes close)
What a ridiculous, juvenile comment to make in response. Your nationalistic cheerleading is just silly. It's a big ol' world.
JustSaying January 20, 2013 at 12:26 am
Jim, that's a bit harsh - Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. It isn't necessary to be insulting.
FU Bob January 20, 2013 at 12:49 am
I just hope the curbs aren't too high. Those always give me trouble...
Jim Williams January 20, 2013 at 03:52 am
Dale comments that I want to outsource the entire project to "Chinese" and "Mexicans" and I'M the one being insulting?! Sheesh.
Roger Thurman January 20, 2013 at 05:25 am
Odd that these design concepts mostly ignore arches, circles and curving walls. One might expect these essential curvilinear elements of the design vocabulary would appear somewhere to offset the multitude of squares, triangles and rectangles. A premium is placed on open interior space to reveal and encourage activity. This seems to jibe with the trends of social networking and diversity but are these proven to enhance focused learning and study? It is certain the completed bulding will be amazing even if the designers appear to be inevitably captured by these times. I anticipated a statement which sums up the entirely of architecture in a completely original and functional manner. That might not have been possible with the requirements for energy efficiency, classroom space and budget limitations. Imagine the difficutly of arriving at a pleasing design which meets all the institutional specifications!
Derek Chang January 20, 2013 at 06:25 am
the architecture's design's of these represent's student's interest. and the important thing is that most of these firm were KSU grads. So they know what it is like being in Kent and Kent State's Architecture student. Having a international firm would just be a wast of money. As respect to curves other architecture feature, I would say that all were design according to the surrounding environment. These archs and circles and curving walls sometimes takes away useful space. More importantly these designs are meant to inform students of what sustainable economy is.
Resident of Kent January 20, 2013 at 02:03 pm
Derek, since these "designs are meant to inform students of what sustainable economy is", I take it that there shall be solar panels out the wazoo and a green roof to capture and re-use rain water as well as runoff? Will there be wind powered generators for the students laptops? No? Well, not a great model for sustainability.
I agree with Mr. Roger Thurman, circles and curves are found all the time in nature- even in the surrounding space of the upcoming building.
Derek Chang January 20, 2013 at 05:33 pm
The green roof are there, on design 1 & 2. To achieve Sustainability, you do not necessary need solar power, they are for places with large land area to be effective in producing power. Add on to that solar panels are expensive. The Arch building was to be built under a budget and to consider a life of a architecture student and its surrounding area. These buildings were also design with architecture student's input. In addition all of the buildings were design to Achieve LEED silver and above.
Charles Crouch January 21, 2013 at 10:39 pm
The WRL proposal looks like an OSU College of Architecture copycat. Bowen's design has some practicality issues, with an overkill of glass that concerns me. ARO/Bialosky seems the most realistic. Were they the only team shooting for LEED Platinum?
Charles Weldy January 22, 2013 at 06:07 pm
Yes, the Bowen design is worrisome in that it is loaded with glass and structures which obviously levitate. Great for a presentation, but creating massive difficulties in heating and cooling - only to be partially mitigated by massively expensive and complicated assemblies. Apparently he assumes a wonderful new source of energy.
Roger Thurman January 23, 2013 at 03:50 am
After viewing the displays at the KSU library I find the Bowen Weiss/Manfredi most inspiring, although my reaction a few days ago was contrary. The extensive use of glass will bring cheerful light info the building to offset our many gray days. This transparency lightens the structure and provides a faceted aesthetic transition from the campus to downtown. In spite of the size and climb of the tiered loft concept it will simulatneously please viewers but not overwhelm. Compared with the others the subtle curving footprint and transparencies convey an almost joyous, wondrous, whimsical aspect. It is so different from the adjacent structures yet it will not diminish them. Witness the garden paths emanating like tendrils from the building's south side openings, arfully blending with the adjacent terrain and houses. The library display presents two models, one in medium aspect to the nearby campus buildings and another much broader to show how the building dwells in the surrounding cityscape. Because of its radient prominence this will be an iconic building for Kent and the university. I can't speak to the issues of maintenance and energy usage compared with the other designs but it seems these architects must know how to handle those equally important aspects.
Matthew DelVillan January 24, 2013 at 08:07 pm
Saw the exhibit too, and Bialosky's model is the best by a landslide. Amazing craft & well translated. It's clear by their display they put the most sweat and tears into the project. (Remember, Weiss/ Manfreidi's public presentation... over half of it was past work / precedent?!? Pair that with a model with no passion. Effort wasn't there.)
brain s April 17, 2013 at 12:35 pm
I do agree Bialosky's is by far the best. I think it may have been a little harsh saying Weiss/Manfreidi's work lacked vision and effort. Often times we stick with what we know and do the best. Like artists, architects tend to work within their comfort zone.
http://www.mccree.com

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Kent Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Linda Davis, founder of Loved Ones of Prisoners, a support group for families.
Sa;;y June 16, 2013 at 05:05 pm
Linda, Kudos! Tough subject to not only approach but create a whole support group. I'm going toRead More pass judgement and say I think you are great!
Sa;;y June 16, 2013 at 04:59 pm
Paula, While I believe there are truly good people out there who have nothing but the bestRead More intentions for others, this story does not shock nor surprise me. I attended meetings with a friend who was court ordered. They couldn't drive and I figured I would sit with them instead of driving back and forth. AA claims not to be a religious sect but all the meetings and steps center around God. Not that I have a problem with God, but some people don't believe. Our courts (Judges) sentence people to attend meetings for DUI. I find this sad and irresponsible. One, it's religion. Two, you are sending alcoholics in to a group of other alcoholics who are not trained to help people with addiction. AA teaches people they are "helpless and powerless". Really? An individual has to find strength from within to fight the addiction. Telling people they are helpless isn't going to help. Alcoholism is usually tied to mental issues or illness. Going into a room and listening to other people's depressing rock bottom stories made me want to leave and go drink. Paradise Club....... hmmmmmmm...... I am not surprised. The only reason these court ordered sessions continue is that it doesn't cost the court any money. DUI's are a money maker for the courts, police and all the attorney's out there. Ah, but that's another story. I hope there is a happy ending for all of those above and others like them who have suffered under the guise of AA.
Amber Rodriguez June 13, 2013 at 12:30 am
I just want to let people know that Dandelion has been found, thank all of you who expressed concernRead More and kept your eyes out for him.
Matt Fredmonsky (Editor) June 5, 2013 at 03:25 pm
Does this not qualify? We're also the only news agency to report if he actually had an explosiveRead More device on him or not. Stories similar to what you've asked for almost all appeared last week. http://kent.patch.com/groups/editors-picks/p/man-arrested-after-threatening-to-set-off-bomb-at-kent-state_593fe0c4
Dave June 5, 2013 at 03:35 pm
Maybe it is just the start to a slow summer or a sign that there is nothing interesting going on inRead More Kent. The story you mentioned turned out to be pretty uneventful and more about a guy making false, not real, threats. The two stories that have seen the most face-time have been KRHS's valedictorian and the med helicopter. Maybe highlight achievements and products of local businesses we don't hear about. Run an interesting historical piece. Not trying to be argumentative but rather making a comment that the information provided as of late has been less than interesting.
amelfo June 7, 2013 at 05:39 pm
Matt -- no need to defend yourself. Considerate of you to respond, though.
Matt Fredmonsky (Editor) June 3, 2013 at 05:12 pm
It seems hardly anyone ever waits until the end of the procession to congratulate all the graduatesRead More at once.
lost cat is on the left in the photo
Patricia June 4, 2013 at 12:52 pm
I posted it to FB too, I live on Wolcott and I saw the flyer yesterday on a pole.
janetstavole June 4, 2013 at 11:00 pm
Thanks to everyone who is helping and has helped. Emmie is still missing but it helps to know soRead More many are looking out for her and us. Thanks again! Janet Stavole
janetstavole June 5, 2013 at 08:14 pm
Happy to report my cat was found....in a friends garage across 43 and about one quarter of a mileRead More away. Thanks to all of you who reposted our information on Facebook. Janet Stavole
Sue May 8, 2013 at 01:47 am
The school levy has passed. This is great news for the children of Kent. Thanks to everyone whoRead More voted for the levy.
Jim Williams May 8, 2013 at 02:05 am
Glad to see that 17% of Kent citizens were able to muster the energy to bother voting, and that theRead More majority of those few supported this very important issue. Congrats to the District for making the convincing argument. It's pretty clear that the chorus of "NO" that exists here on Patch is not representative of the majority.
Concerned Citizen May 8, 2013 at 02:58 am
Good voting LD
Teresa K. April 25, 2013 at 11:18 pm
I'm glad the League did their research. Have they ever researched and said: "no, we dont feelRead More the levy is needed?" For most of us, our research need only go as far as our wallets and income. If the schools with their million dollar budgets are feeling the crunch, imagine how average or lower average income homes are struggling. I am very suspect of the excellent w/ distincton rating and the asking of this levy at this time. How were we able to get that kind of incredible rating with NO ADDED FUNDS? Did the teachers wake up last year? Did the kids wake up? How did the school get such superior ratings THAT year and none in previous ones? why such a huge gap in time and ratings? The days of passing every school levy "just because", "we've never said no", "for the kids" or to keep our "property values" are over. The economy took care of that. No matter how you feel about the levy: PLEASE VOTE.
Sa;;y April 25, 2013 at 11:24 pm
I urge my fellow residents to send a message to the school board: The Board needs to face the factRead More of the current economic conditions involving the residents in the Kent city school district and come back with a request for a more reasonable millage. Otherwise, I think the levy will fail. Our city leaders encouraged businesses to come into the new development by granting concessions on taxes. Well, there goes the additional money!
Sue May 7, 2013 at 12:23 pm
Vote YES today for Kent children. Yes on the school levy.