Kent State Spending $2.2 Million to Buy 7 More Properties for Esplanade
One seller stands to gain $1.85 million from Wednesday's purchase agreement
The Kent State University Board of Trustees on Wednesday approved its single largest, one-time purchase to date of properties related to campus expansion and creation of The Esplanade.
The trustees agreed to spend more than $2.2 million to buy seven residential and commercial structures in the neighborhood west of campus. The parcels are in close proximity to other Kent State-owned properties bought within the past four years along College, Lincoln and Willow streets.
Wednesday's approved expense would bring Kent State's total spent buying land in the neighborhood west of campus since 2007 to above $6 million, and that total excludes the $3.28 million expected for construction costs to actually build the Esplanade extension.
Standing to gain the most from the sales approved Wednesday are Chris Smeiles, a Portage County Commissioner and Kent Realtor.
Kent State is buying the properties “for future expansion of the Kent campus" and the purchases are "consistent with community plans to revitalize the area between the campus and downtown Kent, including extension of the Esplanade to the downtown area," according to the purchase resolution OK’d by university trustees Wednesday.
The properties to be bought through the university’s real estate fund, pending necessary state approvals, are:
- 408 E. Main St. – Currently owned by Smeiles, the 0.177-acre parcel contains a two-story, 3,582-square-foot commercial/rental building constructed in 1920. Its main tenant is Kent Outfitters. An independent appraisal done in September 2010 placed the property value at $375,000.
- 414 E. Main St. – Currently owned by Smeiles, the .033-acre parcel contains a two-story, 6,800-square-foot commercial/office building constructed in 1900. It is home to Cutler Real Estate, and formerly was Century 21 Smeiles Realty. An independent appraisal done in September 2010 placed the property value at $610,000.
While the combined appraised value of the above-listed properties is $985,000, Smeiles agreed to a sale price of $977,500.
- 116 S. Lincoln St. – Currently owned by Kent Campus Rentals LLC, in which Smeiles is a partner, the 0.25-acre parcel contains a two-story, 1,968-square-foot home built in 1900 and registered as a licensed boarding house with the Kent Health Department. A September 2010 appraisal states a value of $352,000; it is being sold for $338,500.
- 129 S. Willow St. – Currently owned by Kent Willow Street Rentals LLC, in which Smeiles is a partner, the 0.27-acre parcel contains a two-story, 1,476-square-foot house built in 1900. It is registered as a licensed boarding house with the Kent Health Department. A September 2010 appraisal states a value of $259,000.
- 117 S. Willow St. – Also owned by Kent Willow Street Rentals LLC, the 0.10-acre parcel contains a two-story, 1,316-square-foot rental house built in 1910. A September 2010 appraisal states a value of $150,000.
- 123 S. Willow St. – Also owned by Kent Willow Street Rentals LLC, the 0.24-acre parcel contains a two-story, 1,344-square-foot rental house built in 1901. A September 2010 appraisal states a value of $145,000.
While the combined appraised value of the three above-listed properties owned by Kent Willow Street Rentals is $554,000, the property owner has agreed to a sale price of $534,500.
These aren't the first properties Chris Smeiles has sold to the university for the Esplanade extension.
In 2010, Smeiles sold a licensed rooming house at 133 S. Willow St. to the university for $255,000. Including all sales, Smeiles stands to gain a potential total of more than $2.1 million in properties he will have had a hand in selling to the university.
Smeiles could not be reached for comment Wednesday evening.
The university also agreed to buy one more property in the area of the Esplanade extension: 402 E. Main St. It's owned by RHS Development, and the 0.19-acre parcel contains a two-story, 3,168-square-foot commercial/rental structure built in 1900. It is home to WordSmiths. An independent appraisal finished in September 2010 placed the property value at $380,000; RHS Development agreed to a sale price of $367,500.
The purchase agreement approved Wednesday states that the current owners wish to continue business operations in all the properties being sold. Therefore, conceptual agreements are being developed that will allow the owners to rent from the university for up to five years.
“The university does not have immediate plans to develop this property, and retaining the structures will not interfere with the extension of the university Esplanade. The financial returns from this conceptual agreement will help reduce the net investment in these properties,” the resolution stated.
In a separate resolution, trustees also agreed to buy property at 428-430 E. College Ave. from Dorothy V. Meyer for $230,000, which is its appraised value. The university also will have an option to purchase Meyers' adjacent property at 308 S. Lincoln St. for $200,000, the appraised value, when it becomes available.
In June, university officials said they had secured all the key properties necessary along the proposed Esplanade route, but that they were still working on buying additional properties necessary to provide landscape buffer areas for the Esplanade extension.
Scroll down for past coverage on Esplanade land buys:
robert
9:50 am on Thursday, September 15, 2011
Why not let KSU buy the whole of kent and just call it KSU. If KSU has so much money mybe they could cut the cost the students must pay to attend this great institution !!!! OH OH maybe the students are helping to buy all this property !!!When will KSU start buying west of the river ?
John Roberts
1:25 am on Friday, September 16, 2011
Where is KSU getting all of this money?
We all know that we homeowners will end up footing the bill for lost property tax. Ah, to be a tax exempt entity.
Jon Ridinger
12:14 pm on Friday, September 16, 2011
John- The KSU has a "real estate fund" that is mentioned in the Record-Courier article on these purchases. They also have the Kent State University Foundation, which raises money on their own. Basically, none of the money for these purchases is coming from tuition.
As for property taxes, just find the properties KSU owns off-campus on the Portage County Auditor's website and you can see exactly how much property tax they pay. For instance, the property at 330 East Erie is listed as being owned by the Kent State University Board of Trustees and it pays $2,852.12 in property tax annually. I'm not sure of the limits of the exemption, but the properties that have buildings on them in the "Campus Link" neighborhood are definitely not exempt. If the university is still using them as a rental, it is not exempt from the tax at least at quick glance. Any properties listed as being owned by the KSU trustees appear to not be tax exempt, but those listed as being owned by the state of Ohio are (and those appear to be vacant land).
David Badagnani
11:40 am on Thursday, September 15, 2011
I'm not sure I understand. Until last week, when biking through the campus and finding it marked as a dotted line on a "You Are Here" map near Satterfield Hall, I couldn't even figure out what "the Esplanade" even was, though it's been discussed as though everyone knew in news articles for a year or more--it sounds like something one would find at the palace of Versailles in France rather than at an Ohio public university. It's the brownish brick walkway that runs from the Student Center to the Fashion Museum, right? I thought that's been finished for several years now. Although it is very attractive and functional, this price tag of so many millions, and the buying of so many properties that are not even on the KSU campus, strikes me as very odd, almost like a project that has grown so large it is now out of control. Does the new $700 student fee I read about recently play into this project?
Matt Fredmonsky
11:46 am on Thursday, September 15, 2011
David, there have been many news articles in various publications documenting the Esplanade project. You're right, right now it's the brick path you've described on campus. The extension project will construct an addition to the Esplanade that carries it through the neighborhood west of campus, where it will eventually link up with the new transit center and hotel in downtown Kent. The proposed new student fee you mentioned is unrelated to the Esplanade and would instead be used to pay for a $250 million renovation of the campus (new windows, heating fixtures, chemistry labs, etc.) Reference the articles at the right of this page for more background on the Esplanade project.
David Badagnani
11:55 am on Thursday, September 15, 2011
Thanks, none of the articles I have seen ever took the time to add a reference for what The Esplanade is, such as: "The Esplanade (the brownish brick-and-concrete walkway running between the Student Center and Fashion Museum)." Thus, although I've walked and biked that path hundreds of times, I never knew that that is what it was called. I thought an esplanade was some sort of plaza rather than a walkway.
Wiktionary calls an esplanade (in lower case) "A clear space between a citadel and the nearest houses of the town." The definition does not mention that houses in the town itself will be needed to be torn down to create an esplanade.
Laurel Myers Hurst
1:06 pm on Thursday, September 15, 2011
:) To make a space, the houses needed to go. The university's commitment to creating (or claiming) space where there exists a rental community (and previously a neighborhood) has been the cause of citizen complaints since the bicentennial plan was announced. What was originally touted as the Campus Link creates space defined by the university to meet its needs and purposes.
In my opinion, the needs of the university community justify this creation/re-creation of space since the landowners are being compensated and their land has NOT been taken by eminent domain. Ultimately, the university's land purchases will give KSU the opportunity to define the use and function of space within the boundaries of SR 43 South, Summit Street, SR 59 and Powdermill Road. That's a MAJOR chunk of real estate!
Laurel Myers Hurst
1:07 pm on Thursday, September 15, 2011
What the university is planning for the future meets the criteria for an esplanade, though what exists presently does not.
Matt Fredmonsky
12:20 pm on Thursday, September 15, 2011
Point well taken.
john Jay
7:06 am on Wednesday, September 21, 2011
Kent State Ubber Allles! Onward, Onward, it marches!