patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Esplanade Takes 41 Properties off Tax Rolls

Kent State University bought properties west of campus to extend pedestrian pathway into downtown

 

In the past six years, Kent State University has bought 41 properties in the neighborhood west of campus to connect the university with downtown Kent via the Esplanade.

The properties bought, about 7.2 acres total, were mostly student rental properties owned by tax-paying private landlords, corporations and private homeowners.

As a state entity, the university does not pay property taxes on land it owns. So property taxes that had been paid on those properties, largely to the benefit of the city and Kent City Schools, will no longer be paid once all the properties are granted tax exempt status as state land.

Combined, the 41 parcels accounted for a total $97,783 in annual property taxes, according to the Portage County Auditor's Office.

We talked with school, university and county officials about this lost tax revenue, and you can read what they had to say on Patch here:

The properties, their sellers and sale price information breaks down as follows:

Address Seller Buyer Sale Price Acreage
329 E. College Ave. Quatro Novus LLC Kent State University $197,500 0.1136
230 S. Willow St. Quatro Novus LLC Kent State University $180,000 0.0884
416 E. College Ave. LKG Inc. Kent State University Board of Trustees $165,000 0.0907
425 E. College Ave. Andrew M. Tonge Kent State University Board of Trustees $120,000 0.1217
428 E. College Ave. Dorothy V. Meyer Kent State University Board of Trustees $230,000 0.1532
429 E. College Ave. Georgelle C. Heintel Kent State University Board of Trustees $130,000 0.0551
324 College Court LKG Corporation Kent State University Board of Trustees n/a 0.1466
Erie St. (vacant land) Pierre Dubois Kent State University Board of Trustees $10,000 0.100
246 Erie St. Larry A. Neiman Kent State University Board of Trustees $225,000 0.1932
250 Erie St. Frank D. Hornyak Kent State University Board of Trustees $225,000 0.2121
320 Erie St. LKG Corporation Kent State University Board of Trustees $170,000 0.2121
324 Erie St. A&H Investments Joint Venture LLC Kent State University Board of Trustees $299,500 0.2159
325 Erie St. Michael W. Smith Kent State University Board of Trustees $125,000 0.1293
329 Erie St. Cynthia Lavelle-Pahl Kent State University Board of Trustees $175,000 0.1263
330 Erie St. Sylvia Liss Kent State University Board of Trustees $180,000 0.0859
116 S. Lincoln St. Kent Campus Rentals LLC Kent State University Board of Trustees $352,000 0.2537
122 S. Lincoln St. Joseph N. Murray Trust Kent State University Board of Trustees $315,000 0.2563
128 S. Lincoln St. A&H Investments Joint Venture LLC Kent State University Board of Trustees $464,000 0.3076
132 S. Lincoln St. David F. and Kathy Schumann Kent State University Board of Trustees n/a 0.233
220 S. Lincoln St. James R. Meeker and Mary Ann Houser Kent State University Board of Trustees $150,000 0.233
402 E. Main St. RHS Development Inc. Kent State University Board of Trustees $380,000 0.1932
408 E. Main St. Christopher & Deborah Smeiles Kent State University Board of Trustees $375,000 0.1771
414 E. Main St. Christopher & Deborah Smeiles Kent State University Board of Trustees $610,000 0.257
116 S. Willow St. Michael P. & Linda M. Dussell Kent State University Board of Trustees $145,000 0.1178
117 S. Willow St. Kent Willow St. Rentals Kent State University Board of Trustees $150,000 0.1065
122 S. Willow St. David & Amy Adams Kent State University Board of Trustees $141,000 0.1263
123 S. Willow St. Kent Willow St. Rentals Kent State University Board of Trustees $145,000 0.2397
128 S. Willow St. Andrej M. Petryna Kent State University Board of Trustees $225,000 0.1263
129 S. Willow St. Kent Willow St. Rentals Kent State University Board of Trustees $259,000 0.2703
133 S. Willow St. Kent Campus Rentals LLC Kent State University Board of Trustees $255,000 0.2703
204 S. Willow St. Christopher & Robin Heiman Kent State University Board of Trustees $200,000 0.120
205 S. Willow St. Barbara L. Hartz Kent State University Board of Trustees $210,000 0.233
214 S. Willow St. Joshua R. Greene Kent State University Board of Trustees
$133,500 0.202
219 S. Willow St. David & Amy Adams Kent State University Board of Trustees $132,500 0.2703
220 S. Willow St. Joshua R. Greene Kent State University Board of Trustees $133,500 0.202
225 S. Willow St. David & Patricia Nichols Kent State University Board of Trustees $155,000 0.2037
231 S. Willow St. Messersmith UniTrust Kent State University Board of Trustees $125,000 0.0918
208 S. Lincoln St. Jay & Margie Waliga Kent State University Board of Trustees $450,000 0.2889
308 S. Lincoln St. Dorothy V. Meyer (pending transfer/purchase agreement)
0.1814
209 S. Willow St. MCP Willow 209 LLC Kent State University Board of Trustees $570,000 0.3076
210 S. Willow St. Michael & Clarissa Weiner Kent State University Board of Trustees $400,000 0.202
Totals:
41 properties $8,907,500 7.3949

The information in this graph is based on data from the Portage County Auditor's Office and Kent State University.

Related Topics: Esplanade, Kent State University, Property Tax, and tax exempt

Jeff Wissler

9:41 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

OK. Now add up all the values of the properties which will increase the tax base due to the new construction (Acorn Alley, Davey Tree, Ametek, Hotel renovation, etc.). That would be an interesting comparison.

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Matt Fredmonsky

10:02 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

Jeff, some interesting things to note about those properties include the fact the new Davey Tree, AMETEK and Kent State Hotel buildings are in a TIF district, which makes the properties tax exempt in exchange for annual payments to the school district based on the values of those buildings (how much those annual payments will be is unclear until all construction is finished). The new PARTA Kent Central Gateway is tax exempt also as a government entity owned building. And Acorn Alley is in a community reinvestment district, which has a lowered tax rate.

Shannon McKee

9:56 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

I don't think it helps the conversation at all for us townies to constantly pit the university against the town. There is give and take in both directions. (And, no, I'm not an employee of the university.) And, while it will drop some tax revenues, let's be honest: a good number of those properties were eye sores where a lot of the May partying always took place (which had its own costs to the city). So, yes, it's a valid question to ask about those revenues for our schools (which I have two children in) but must we ALWAYS slant it in the worst possible direction?

Reply

David Badagnani

11:08 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

Who is hiding behind the name "MCP Willow 209 LLC" (now $570K richer)?

And why did realtor Christopher Smeiles make so much more than everyone else for his properties?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Traci Monroe

11:34 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

You'll never get an honest answer to those questions, we all know why Smeiles got so much.

Comment_arrow

David Badagnani

11:58 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

This article may explain something about it. Smeiles was apparently unavailable for comment at the time.

http://kent.patch.com/articles/kent-state-spending-22-million-to-buy-7-more-properties-for-esplanade

Comment_arrow

Chris (Kit) Myers

12:09 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

Nobody is "hiding." The name showing is the name of the company that owned and sold it.
What must be considered is what is left after the government gets done with extracting taxes and all other expenses are paid. For instance, I own 224 South Willow Street. Kent State has offered me $538,000 for it. The Feds alone will take $132,000 in taxes, and that is just the Feds. I owe $48,000 to the bank. That leaves me with $358,000.
You must understand that that property is my only asset in the world. Furthermore, it is my JOB! It is my INCOME! It is my LEGACY TO MY CHILDREN!
I love the place. I love my student tenants. I am there almost every day doing something. It is as nice. Drive by it and check out the lawn and the roses and the clematis and the salvia.
The economy is rather flat these days, and banks are paying zip for interest. Inflation will eat away at the money. It is no time for me to sell it AND BE OUT OF A JOB!
Some of us have busted our butts for what we have. Don't we deserve the fruits of our labors for the rest of our lives? Would you have Kent State take away my job? My income?
There you have it. You may not understand, but I do. I just cannot let the property go at the offered price which you probably think is exhorbitant.
I would protect you in the same situation.

Jeff Wissler

11:51 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

Thanks for the explanation Matt. I was wondering about the tax status of the new construction. I think it is still best to compare the "bottom line" to the schools when all the construction is finshed.

Reply

Jon Ridinger

1:04 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

Patch's own article from February stated that the Province at Kent on South Lincoln Street would generate around $240,000/year in property tax. Not sure if that's still (or ever was) accurate (the article was about the complex's initial zoning denial), but if it is, then that more than offsets the losses from KSU purchases. http://kent.patch.com/articles/south-lincoln-apartment-complex-rezoning-denied-by-kent-council.

I hope no one is surprised that KSU buying property takes it off the table as far as property taxes go, though it doesn't take it off automatically. Many of the houses the KSU Foundation bought were still occupied and thus, the KSU Foundation was still paying property tax on them until they became vacant. Kent State also owns the properties along East Main where Wordsmith's, Cutler Real Estate, and Kent Outfitters are located. Those most definitely pay property tax according to the Portage County Auditor's website. .

If you want to get upset about tax-exempt land in the Kent City Schools, look up how much land the city of Akron owns in Franklin Township for their water supply and treatment plant, something that often gets overlooked. It's an area as large (if not larger) than campus and unlike KSU, provides zero economic trade-offs for the area.

Reply

Clarissa

11:59 am on Monday, March 25, 2013

@david badagnan, I don't think Smeiles made the most off the two properties that he listed.

Reply

Clarissa

12:01 pm on Monday, March 25, 2013

And the reason some made more than others is because they didn't jump at the first order from KSU.

Reply

Clarissa

12:14 pm on Monday, March 25, 2013

And the reason some made more than others is because they didn't jump at the first offer from KSU.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Matt Fredmonsky

9:12 am on Tuesday, March 26, 2013

A comment was removed for violating Patch's terms of use. http://kent.patch.com/terms

Reply

Chris (Kit) Myers

1:14 pm on Tuesday, March 26, 2013

Anybody know who the Clarissa is who decided to make an inaccurate comment about me that is certainly defamation of my character? If so, please give me a call at (330) 678-6984. Thanks, Chris

Reply

Leave a comment